All teardowns

home & cookware · Teardown

Our Place

A bundle-led store that already monetises: the PDP defaults to a 16-piece set and pushes an 18-piece "MOST SAVINGS" tier, and the drawer runs a free-ship bar plus a cross-sell. The second-sale money left on the phone: no bump at the add moment, a cross-sell that opens at $84, and a free-ship reward with no tier behind it.

Built withShopifyKlarna (installments / Check purchase power)Cookie/consent banner (vendor tracking + Cookie Preferences)Reviews platform (60,689 aggregated reviews / star widget)Owned slide-out cart drawer (custom, with progress bar + Pairs Well With carousel)

Our Place already does the hard part: the merchandising backbone is bundles, the PDP defaults to "Cookware Set+ (16 Piece)" and upsells an 18-piece "MOST SAVINGS" tier, and the cart drawer carries a free-shipping bar and a "Pairs Well With" carousel. So our read is about the AOV that compounds on top of all that. On mobile the attach moment is empty, the cross-sell opens with a considered $84 buy, and the free-ship reward clears with nothing behind it. We mapped the second-sale gaps the way a phone buyer hits them (bump, threshold, cart goal) and where each one feeds the next order.

Home page

01 · CROHome: the first phone screen is a testimonial, not a way in
Our Place mobile home opening on a Kenji Lopez-Alt testimonial carousel with no hero CTA
MEDIUM

Mobile home leads with a testimonial carousel: a "PRO COOKWARE SET / NOCO" image and autoplay video, "Titanium Nonstick", and the line "The surface is all clad with titanium… it's just durable. — J. Kenji Lopez-Alt", with arrows and five dots. There's no hero headline, value prop, or shop CTA ahead of it.

Fix: A vague first screen thins the pool of buyers who reach any offer, and every order we lose at the top is an order we can't attach a bump or cross-sell to later. We'd merge a tight value line and a "Shop" CTA into that first screen so more qualified traffic lands on the PDP where the bundle and the second sale actually live.

02 · CROHome: bestseller cards, tap targets and the missing quick-add
Our Place mobile bestseller cards with discount badges and small color swatches, no quick-add
LOW

The "Shop Bestsellers" rail runs cards with savings badges ("$299 SET SAVINGS", "SALE | $70 OFF"): "Titanium Pro Cookware Set (10 piece) $399 ($698 Value)", "Wonder Oven Pro $255 $325", each with a row of tiny color swatches and no Add button; the whole tile routes to the PDP.

Fix: This rail is high-intent, set-priced traffic, and right now every tap means a full PDP load before anything can be added. Bigger swatch targets plus an optional quick-add would let these sets enter the cart faster, and the sooner a set is in the basket, the sooner the drawer cross-sell gets its shot at a second item.

03 · BaselineHome: proof and shipping reassurance left as decorationBaseline redesign
Our Place mobile home marquee and "Over 100,000 5-star reviews" band with no adjacent shop CTA
LOW

Home scrolls a marquee ("FREE RETURNS · FREE SHIPPING OVER $…") above an "Over 100,000 5-star reviews for our award-winning products" band, with a Food Network press quote further down. The free-shipping threshold appears as decorative marquee text rather than a concrete number wired to the cart.

Fix: A threshold shown as moving text does nothing for AOV: it never tells the shopper how much more to add. We'd state it as a specific, cart-linked line ("Free shipping over $135") so it becomes a spend target on home, then carry the same number into the drawer goal. As a Baseline pass it turns a decorative claim into the first rung of a spend ladder.

Product page

04 · CROPDP: a 13,794px page with one Add to Cart and no sticky bar
Our Place mobile PDP buy box with the only Add to Cart near the top of a very tall page
HIGH

At 13,794px tall on mobile, the PDP carries exactly one Add to Cart: the terracotta button up near the top 13%, beneath the "Cookware + Bakeware Set (18 Piece)" tier card. We scrolled the entire page and found no fixed buy action across any band: specs, What's Included, editorial, FAQ, and reviews all pass with the cart action gone from view.

Fix: Every AOV mechanic we want to add downstream depends on getting the order placed first, and on this length the add button vanishes after a single swipe. A sticky bottom bar (price and "Add to Cart") restored the moment the buy box leaves the viewport keeps the order in reach, and it's the surface we'd later hang a bump on too.

Our Place mobile PDP opening on benefits and a related-products accordion above the option selector
MEDIUM

The page begins with a "BENEFITS" block and a related-products accordion (Perfect Pot, Large Always Pan, Mini Always Pan 2.0); the "Select Option" tier selector and the terracotta button only show up further down, sitting beneath spec bullets and a stack of internal cross-links.

Fix: Burying the tier selector under specs costs us the moment a shopper picks the higher bundle. We'd lift the option selector and Add to Cart above the spec content so the 18-piece "MOST SAVINGS" upgrade is the first thing in reach: the closer the tier choice is to the top, the more upgrades clear before fatigue sets in.

05 · CROPDP: the cookie card lands on top of the buy controls
Our Place cookie consent card covering the option selector and color swatches on the mobile PDP
MEDIUM

A consent card ("Our Place and our vendors use cookies… Terms of Service … Privacy Policy … Cookie Preferences") loads as a large opaque overlay parked across the "Select Option — Cookware Set+ (16 Piece)" header and the "Color — Steam" swatches. We saw the same card return over the "Shop Bestsellers" area on home.

Fix: An overlay over the tier and color controls forces a dismiss before the shopper can even configure, and the configure step is where the bundle upgrade is won or lost. Re-anchoring consent to a slim bottom bar clears the buy controls so the higher-value tier is selectable from the first second the page settles.

06 · BaselinePDP: trust is excellent, and it lives far below the buttonBaseline redesign
Our Place mobile PDP trust icons and 60,689-review accordion sitting far below the buy box
MEDIUM

Underneath the buy box the PDP lines up "Why You'll Love It" bullets, three trust icons ("3-Year Warranty", "100-Day Trial", "Free Shipping & Returns"), a "SEE WHAT PEOPLE THINK!" UGC strip, and the "REVIEWS (60,689)" accordion, while the buy box itself only shows "Free shipping $135+ and free returns" and Klarna.

Fix: The reassurance that justifies a $449–$459 set sits hundreds of pixels under the add button, so it can't do its job at the tier decision. Pulling a compact trust line (trial · warranty · 60,689 reviews) into the buy box is a Baseline move that raises confidence right where the higher bundle is chosen, and confident buyers reach for the bigger set.

07 · UpsellrPDP: no bump at the highest-intent tapUpsellr / ISS
Our Place mobile PDP Add to Cart with only shipping and Klarna lines beneath it, no bump
Bundles & kitsHIGH

Right under the terracotta button the PDP carries only "Free shipping $135+ and free returns", "From $41/month or 0% interest with Klarna · Check purchase power", and footnotes: no order bump, no "Frequently bought together", no low-ticket add at the add moment. The 18-piece "MOST SAVINGS" tier is the lone AOV lever on the page.

Fix: The instant a shopper picks the bundle and taps add is the highest-intent second in the funnel, and it's carrying nothing. We'd attach one relevant lower-ticket bump beside the button: a consumable, a utensil, a care or refill item. It's the invisible second sale: it lifts AOV on its own click without disturbing the bundle tier the page already sells well.

Cart drawer

08 · UpsellrCart: free-ship already cleared, cross-sell leads with $84Upsellr / ISS
Our Place slide-out cart drawer with a cleared free-shipping bar and the Pairs Well With cross-sell carousel leading with the $84 Titanium Mini Perfect Pot Pro
Cart goals & reward laddersHIGH

The owned drawer opens with a "Congrats! You get free standard shipping" bar whose meter is already full on this $459 order (Cookware Set+, "Steam", $459 / $677 Value, qty stepper and Edit). Under the line item the "Pairs Well With" carousel opens on the "Titanium Mini Perfect Pot Pro" at $84 (was $169) with a finish selector, an ADD button, and an arrow onward; the footer shows "Savings -$218", subtotal, "Add gift note", and "Continue to Checkout".

Fix: Two AOV levers are idle here. The free-ship reward is already won with no next tier, so the spend ladder dead-ends: we'd stack a second goal above it (a gift-with-purchase at the next threshold) to keep a reason to add. And opening the carousel on an $84 considered buy is a hard yes in a narrow drawer; we'd lead with a sub-$30 one-tap impulse add. Validate any threshold discount against your margins before locking it in.

Cross-sellsMEDIUM

The "Pairs Well With" slot is durable cookware (the Mini Perfect Pot Pro), not a refill, consumable, or care item, and the line item is a one-time durable set with nothing in the drawer that earns a repeat order.

Fix: Cross-selling another pot onto a one-time set gives us a single bump and no LTV: cookware barely repurchases. We'd put a consumable or care attach in the carousel (a ceramic-safe cleaner, replacement utensils, an oven mat) so the second sale is both cheaper to win now and the seed of a third sale on reorder.

Screens

Mobile
Home page — mobile

What we'd fix

Baseline redesign
  1. 1Restore a sticky mobile Add to Cart (price + button) the instant the buy box scrolls off, so the order (and the upsells that ride on it) stay reachable across a 13,794px PDP.
  2. 2Drop consent to a slim bottom bar so it stops blocking the tier selector and swatches, keeping the 18-piece "MOST SAVINGS" upgrade selectable from load.
  3. 3Pull a compact trust line (trial · warranty · 60,689 reviews) into the buy box so confidence lands at the tier decision and more buyers reach for the larger set.
Upsellr / ISS
  1. 1Attach one low-ticket bump beside Add to Cart (consumable / utensil / care): the highest-intent tap currently has no second-sale offer at all.
  2. 2Open the cart "Pairs Well With" carousel with a sub-$30 one-tap impulse add and push the $84 Mini Perfect Pot Pro further down the rail.
  3. 3Layer a second cart goal above the cleared free-ship bar and swap in a consumable/care cross-sell so the second sale also drives a reorder on otherwise one-time cookware.

Want these upsells live without dev?

Build this with Upsellr.

Install Upsellr